adverb

HSK1 TBCL2
‘also, too’

Common errors

Incorrect position

1. Learners might place 也 at sentence-initial position of the second clause.

*我想喝茶,也他想。
我想喝茶,他想。

*我想喝茶,也他想。
我想喝茶,他想。

2. Learners might place 也 directly before a noun.

*我喜欢中文,也英文。
我喜欢中文,喜欢英文。
我喜欢中文和英文。

*我喜歡中文,也英文。
我喜歡中文,喜歡英文。
我喜歡中文和英文。

3. When 也 co-occurs with other adverbs, learners might place 也 in a wrong position.

*他们都也想去中国。
他们也都想去中国。

*他們都也想去中國。
他們也都想去中國。

Confusion between 也 and 还/還

Learner might confuse 也 and 还/還, which can both be translated as “also”. Although these two adverbs can be used interchangeably sometimes, they have different focuses: 也 emphasizes the “sameness”, whereas 还/還 introduces additional information.

我学英语,也学日语。
I learn both English and Japanese.

我学英语,还学日语。
In addition to English, I also learn Japanese.

我學英語,也學日語。
I learn both English and Japanese.

我學英語,還學日語。
In addition to English, I also learn Japanese.

When two different subjects perform the same action or share common properties, only 也 can be used.

*我会唱歌,他还会唱歌。
我会唱歌,他会唱歌。

我會唱歌,他還會唱歌。
我會唱歌,他會唱歌。

Errors caused by native transfer

In English, the adverb also has a relatively flexible position in a sentence. As a result, English speakers might place 也 in incorrect positions when translating or constructing sentences in Chinese.

Classroom activity

1

Make it clear that 也 cannot be placed before the subject but must be placed before the verb. Ask a question to elicit a positive response from a student. Then ask another student to summarize. For example:

Teacher: 我想去中国,你呢?/我想去中國,你呢?
Student 1: 我不想。
Teacher: (towards student 2) 你呢?
Student 2: 我想(去)。
Teacher: (towards student 3) 所以……
Student 3: 老师想去中国/老師想去中國,Student 2 也想(去)。

Other examples are 喜欢学中文/喜歡學中文, 觉得茶好喝/覺得茶好喝, or 会写汉字/會寫漢字……

2

Remind the learners that 也 cannot be placed before a noun but must be placed before a verb or a modal verb. Ask questions to elicit two positive or two negative answers, then ask another student to summarize. For example:

Teacher: 你喝茶吗?
Student 1: 我喝茶。
Teacher: 你喝可乐吗/你喝可樂嗎?
Student 1: 我不喝可乐/我不喝可樂。
Teacher: 你喝水吗/你喝水嗎?
Student 1: 我喝水。
Teacher:  (towards student 2) 所以……
Student 2:  Student 1 喝茶,也喝水。

Teacher: 你喝茶吗/你喝茶嗎?
Student 1: 我喝茶。
Teacher: (towards student 2) 你喝茶吗/你喝茶嗎?
Student 2: 我不喝茶。
Teacher: (towards student 3) 你喝茶吗/你喝茶嗎?
Student 3: 我不喝茶。
Teacher: (towards student 4) 所以……
Student 4:  Student 2不喝茶,student 3也不喝茶。

This exercise format not only benefits familiarity with this grammar point but also enhances class interaction and students’ listening comprehension.

Other possible thematic fields for practicing 也 are food and drinks, family members, hobbies, etc.